Proposed Housing Bill Would Create a Co-Op of Mortgage Lenders

March 27, 2014
New York Times 
mortgage lending news
Rep. Maxine Waters (D-Calif.) believes the housing finance system should act more like a public utility, a concept backed by consumer advocates like the Center for Responsible Lending. The lawmaker is proposing a reform bill that would create a co-op of lenders that would serve as the sole issuer of mortgage-backed securities insured by the government. Private backers would be required to take the first 5 percent loss before the government guarantee takes effect.

Karen Shaw Petrou, managing partner at Federal Financial Analytics, points to adequate private-sector capital as a concern. "A utility, or co-op, may solve for that because it creates a special purpose entity that doesn't need to meet shareholder demand the same way a big bank or bondholder does," she explains.

Waters' proposal would establish a new federal regulator. A minimum down payment of 3.5 percent would be expected from a first-time buyer and 5 percent from everyone else, although the regulator would have the authority to lower those requirements.

One reason that CRL and other supporters are receptive to the co-op format is because it would create a single entity that could be held responsible for making sure that mortgages are available in all markets. It also would deter cherry-picking of loans in more desirable or profitable areas. “If you’re going to have a duty-to-serve requirement, then there is a question about how you enforce it if there’s multiple guarantors,” said CRL executive director Gary Kalman. “If somebody’s not serving South Dakota, who do you hold accountable?”

Abstract News © Copyright 2008-2013 INFORMATION, INC.
Powered by Information, Inc.

Stay Updated

Join the fight against predatory lending. Enter your e-mail to sign up for breaking news, action alerts, and CRL's original research.

   Please leave this field empty

Help Us End Predatory Lending

Predatory lending destroys family wealth, and preys on our most vulnerable communities. You can help us end abusive lending practices by donating to CRL, or by sharing our work with others.